—Jessica Duffy, US Eventing
This article was originally published by the US Eventing Association.
It’s been nearly three months since USEA recognized competitions were suspended in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, but this past weekend saw competitors returning to the field of play at three events across the country: River Glen in New Market, Tennessee; Feather Creek in Norman, Oklahoma; and Plantation Field in Unionville, Pennsylvania. The USEA was on the ground at Plantation Field on Friday to observe the joy and excitement of the first day back competing since mid-March.
Plantation Field offered Beginner Novice through Intermediate levels with Intermediate, Preliminary, and Open Training all running as one-day events on Friday and the remaining Training divisions, Novice, and Beginner Novice following suit on Saturday. From contactless packet pick-up and temperature checks at the entrance to drive-thru fence judge orientation, there were plenty of changes to be seen around the event designed to keep competitors, staff, and volunteers safe.
“We knew we had to get this right and we had to do it in a way that people outside the eventing world could see that this is a no-contact sport where we can maintain social distance,” said Mary Coldren, Plantation Field’s event organizer. “It was important to us to show that this can be done in a way that follows CDC guidelines and hopefully it will benefit other events for the rest of the season. I sent an email to the competitors last week that said, ‘All eyes are on us. This will not look like pictures you see at the beach. We are going to wear masks and we are going to social distance. We’re going to do this right.’”
Coldren said it came down to the wire as far as gaining approval to run, as Pennsylvania only entered “Phase Yellow” on Friday – the stay-at-home orders for Chester County extended through Thursday night. “We didn’t get permission until 8:45 p.m. on Monday night,” she said. “All along, no one would say, ‘yes,’ but no one said, ‘no’ either. That was one of the hard parts – are we or aren’t we, maybe we can, maybe we can’t? Two weeks ago, I thought we had no chance. We rolled the dice and got set up and got lucky that it worked out!”
(Photo credit: USEA/Jessica Duffy Photo)
Coldren noted that special thanks were due to Denis Glaccum, President of Plantation Field Equestrian Events, Inc., for making sure the event got the go-ahead to take place. “He really deserves the credit for having a positive attitude and making the presentation that got us the permission to run. I was doubtful, but he never gave up!”
“The whole concept of trying to put on an event with no face-to-face interaction with people has been challenging,” Coldren admitted. Instead of allowing competitors into the secretary’s office on the day of the event, competitors were encouraged to email ahead of time with questions. For day-of issues, important phone numbers were posted around the event so competitors could call instead of going to the secretary’s office. “Trying to get everything set and settled prior to arrival was key, so then when competitors arrived they could just compete and didn’t have to deal with any administrative stuff. It was a huge culture change, but in a lot of ways it made the day of a lot easier.”
The silver lining of the new restrictions, Coldren said, has been the entry into the age of what she calls “contactless eventing.” Entries, which she said are typically less than 50 percent complete come the morning of the competition, were 99 percent complete prior to the start of the event because of the need to avoid the contact associated with last-minute paperwork in the secretary’s office. “I’ve been trying to get riders to send me complete entries for 15 years!” she laughed. “We’re in the digital age now – we have online payments and everything can be submitted electronically.”
As one of the first events “out of the gate,” so to speak, with the new COVID-19 regulations, Coldren said there’s still going to be trial and error as they work out how to do things as safely and efficiently as possible. For example, Coldren made sure disinfecting wipes were available in show jumping warm-up to wipe down the poles and jump cups but forgot to make sure there were trash cans available for people to throw away their used wipes. “Luckily we had everything we needed here but trying to think of everything ahead of time was tricky.”
“The competitors have been spectacular,” Coldren praised. “They’ve been completely patient with the delays in scoring, avoiding face-to-face contact, doing things digitally and electronically. I think they were all just so happy to be out here and they realize the struggles that we’re having to meet all these new guidelines and procedures.”
“I think the thing that I miss the most is that Plantation usually has quite a hospitality aspect for all our volunteers and officials and everyone else,” Coldren said. “I think not having burgers on the grill or cinnamon buns for the volunteers in the morning and everyone hanging out having lunch together, that part of it I miss. But we just couldn’t do it this time. And to see the side of the hill here with no spectators on it – normally we have a good group of neighbors who come out and sit on the hill to watch the event and having to say ‘no spectators’ was tough to do, but everyone understood.”
Officials and volunteers alike had to adjust to new procedures designed to help them maintain social distance in the area of the sport where people have the most face-to-face contact outside the secretary’s office. Plantation tackled the issue of social distancing for the dressage judges by having the judge and the scribe park their cars next to each other and speak through the open window (or by walkie-talkie if the weather required them to roll up their windows.)
“Judging with a scribe has been a bit of a challenge,” said Anne Moss, one of Plantation’s dressage judges, “but it’s actually worked surprisingly well. My scribe has been taking the scores on one sheet, and I have a separate score sheet where I do the collective marks, and then they get stapled together. We’ve been putting our papers in plastic folders that have been sanitized, my bell was sanitized, we’re all wearing masks when we’re within six feet of each other. It’s definitely a little different, but Mary Coldren has done a fantastic job organizing all this and thinking about the safest ways to move forward.”
Moss commented that she was impressed by the quality of the work she saw horses and riders putting forward in the sandbox and that the extra time people had to do their homework really seemed to have paid off. “It’s been an interesting spring for all of us, and it was nice to see that everyone has had extra time to practice their dressage!” she said. “I saw some really lovely tests. I was judging Intermediate this morning and sometimes for those horses, maybe it’s their first season and they’re still struggling, but I saw a lot of strengths out there today which was great to see.”
Kristin Schlachter, an eventer who operates Silverhorn Equestrian just down the road from Plantation Field, said she was a little bummed she wasn’t riding this weekend but was happy she could come out and lend a hand as a fence judge for the afternoon. Fence judges were asked to watch the USEA Jump Judge Instructional Videos ahead of time and then were given a short orientation from the Technical Delegate over the radio once they were in place at their fences. “I’m so excited,” she said of being out at a horse show for the first time in months. “The weather is beautiful, the ground looks amazing – everything is wonderful. I wish I was riding, but I’m also happy to be volunteering.”
Steve Berkowitz was the on-site veterinarian from Unionville Equine Associates at Plantation on Friday and observed that, with respect to the new COVID-19 restrictions, most everyone was respecting the new guidelines. “Everyone is doing everything we’ve been told to do and we’re very aware of the responsibility we have to follow the rules and set a good example for everybody else,” he said. “So far, today’s been very good. Usually, it goes very well here – Plantation Field has a great team. The footing’s always good, they have the best people, we’ve been helping out here for years, and everyone knows what to do.”
Cross-country course designer Jeff Kibbie pointed out that, because of the competition suspension, Plantation Field was actually the first event on the Area II competition calendar to take place in 2020. Because it was effectively the beginning of the season for many riders, he said, “I tried to keep the courses nice and open so everyone could get out there and have a good gallop and a good ride. Hopefully, everyone’s horses are coming across the line more confident and happy.”
Jennie Brannigan, who had five horses to compete on Friday – three in the Intermediate, one in the Preliminary, and one in the Training – said that she was pleased to see how easy it was for everyone to social distance. “I think Plantation did a great job of keeping everyone far away from each other and keeping the entry numbers low, so that was really good,” she said. “I think it felt very safe because everyone was really far away from each other. It made me realize that eventing is actually able to do this and still be socially distant. I feel confident that it was a good day for the sport and everyone was safe.”
Brannigan explained that, with the exception of a couple of weeks off at the beginning of quarantine, she’s been keeping her horses going throughout the suspension. “I think quarantine’s been good because we’ve trained our horses well – I’ve had a ton of lessons with my showjumping trainer Scott Keach and my dressage trainer James Burtwell, and then, of course, working with Erik Duvander,” she said. “And my whole staff is feeling revived because we’ve been getting done at a good time and we’ve gotten a lot of things cleaned so that’s been good.” Today was a chance for some of her horses to get out and stretch their legs in preparation for the fall season.
“I’m happy with the way things came out,” Coldren concluded. “Are there are some things that we could have done better or differently or more efficiently? Yes. But there has been no place that you see a gathering of people, and to me, that was an important goal to have and we achieved it. Even in the parking area and up on the hill people were really respecting the guidelines. If you see three people standing together, they’re all from the same household.”
For more great eventing stories, visit our Eventing Page.